The church market is dominated by Guide One, Church Mutual, and Brotherhood Mutual. Fortunately, I have a market that matches up well against those three both from a pricing and coverage standpoint. A lot of insurance companies say they like churches but they are missing some critical coverage churches need.
Check out Church Underwriters in the Minneapolis area and if they are in your state, they will have a competitive market or two for you. If you do, tell Eric that Air Jer sent you.