I don't know that I still have anything on file, but I put it together in less than an hour. Like I said, the administrator I use had a good presentation and was a good presentor, I did almost zero work there. For my case study portion, I simply grabbed three one page presentations from my client files, whited out the names, and made copies. The presentation was simply walking the audience through all three options.
The scenerios:
1. A co-pay vs. an
HSA plan. I actually used this to tell show my audience how over-hyped HSAs are for group plans (although great for the self employed). I showed the savings created by switching and how most of the savings goes back to the employees in the form of an employer
HSA contribution. Great for the employees, sucks for the employer paying the majority of the bill.
I explained how this could be a good concept if you as the employer are not feeling a strain from the benefits, have a relatively healthy group, and simply want to pass on an added benefit to your employees. If you are looking for real cost savings, the other two options may fit better.
2. I then showed an
HRA type arrangement compared to a co-pay plan with a $500 deductible. The example showed a $1500 Ded. without office visit co-pays, but with Rx co-pays. I showed in the one page example how the employer could set-up an
HRA to reimburse the employees up to "x" amount each year, but unlike the
HSA, keep the unused amounts at year end. Most small groups haven't seen this strategy before and it can work magic when it works.
3. There were some small employers in attendance without group plans, so I showed option #3 as simply giving the employees a flat dollar amount allowance and setting up a 125 plan to allow the employees to pre-tax the allowance.
I concluded by saying "none of the three strategies are a magic bullet, but if your current broker hasn't discussed these with you already, you deserve to take a look at them and make your own decision. If you want my help taking a look, let me know."
*As a side note, another broker in town showed up and heckled us with questions to try and make us look stupid. After being called out, he got quiet and looked like the unprofessional one.