Over 150.000 insurance professionals and consumers come to the Insurance Forum every month. Click here to register for FREE


Go Back   Insurance Forums > Insurance Agents and Brokers Forum > P&C Insurance Forum

Reply to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family     
Old 04-12-2017, 10:04 PM   #11
Guru
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts:538
State: todd02 is an Insurance Agent from Alabama
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Originally Posted by indienoise View Post
Is it just me who thinks access to this information, consumed mostly by farmers agents, will cause the number of farmers agents to suddenly decrease???
Food for thought.
What???? Number of Agents will decrease. District managers will decrease as well
------------------------------------
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-19-2017, 06:45 PM   #12
Guru
AZDave on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts:501
State: AZDave is an Insurance Agent from Arizona
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family AZDave is the thread starter for: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family

For anyone interested in this case, here's news:

On April 18, 2017, after a two week trial an advisory jury returned a unanimous decision in the plaintiffs’ favor, finding that the agents were employees under ERISA.

Court still must confirm or reject the jury verdict. If the judge confirms, the the case goes to the next phase to determine scope of relief.

Still not over, but AMFAM is losing, and has lost again.

------------------------------------
A bad day of fishing is better than......
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-19-2017, 08:36 PM   #13
Guru
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts:538
State: todd02 is an Insurance Agent from Alabama
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Wow.... this is pretty bad for AMFAM
------------------------------------
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-20-2017, 02:40 PM   #14
Guru
VolAgent on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts:12,987
State: VolAgent is an Insurance Agent from Tennessee
VolAgent is a member of 5000 posts Super VIP club
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Originally Posted by todd02 View Post
Wow.... this is pretty bad for AMFAM
It won't be just AMFAM. I doubt their structure is vastly different than any other captive, so all the captive companies may be facing a similar lawsuit from their agents. Particularly those that incurred huge losses and failed out for whatever reason.

There will almost certainly be huge changes coming to the captives, the question is what. FedEx Ground solved their problem by no longer hiring individual drivers but firms who hired individual drivers. How will captives solve their problem should this decision stand on appeal?

------------------------------------
You can pay the premium or you can own the loss.
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-21-2017, 02:56 PM   #15
Guru
shawnmwalker on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts:799
State: shawnmwalker is an Insurance Agent from Undisclosed Location
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
The NAAFA Home Page

"JAMMAL V AMERICAN FAMILY;
THE UNANIMOUS JURY VERDICT IS THAT AGENTS ARE, IN FACT, EMPLOYEES. THE AGENTS WON!!
It will be some time before the judge comes back with the penalty, but just knowing that the jury agreed with Plaintiffs on behalf of the agents is awesome. Hey, give God the GLORY!* 4/18/2017"

----------

Jury says American Family Insurance misclassified agents in class action seeking retirement benefits | cleveland.com

"The jury apparently agreed that AmFam cannot have it both ways," Erin Dickinson, a Milwaukee-area attorney who worked on the case, said in the news release.*"A company cannot just call its agents 'independent contractors' to avoid following the federal law protecting retirement benefits and then insist on controlling how those agents do their work."

"We strongly disagree with the advisory verdict and believe it is contrary to the facts that American Family treats our agents as the independent contractors that they are," Muth's statement says. "The classification of insurance agents as independent contractors is common in our industry and has been affirmed by the courts in the past. Not only does our agents' independent-contractor designation comply with the law, it benefits our agents by providing them great independence to make their businesses successful."

The jury's decision in this case mirrors litigation underway across the country that seeks benefits and payment standards for people*who work at*companies that classify workers*as independent contractors.

------------------------------------
Regards,


Shawn M. Walker
Vice President
Premier Group Insurance
www.PGIAgents.com
720.335.3799
Captive: Prisoner
Independent: Freedom
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-21-2017, 04:31 PM   #16
Guru
insurance1822 on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts:1,618
State: insurance1822 is an Insurance Agent from Alabama
insurance1822 is a member of 1000 posts VIP club
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
so what does this "really" mean? Other captives allow agents to sell their BOB (whereas apparently Amfam does not?) Other captives don't control who agents hire (at least nothing extreme..) so I don't see how this spills over?

Was AMFAM abusing the captive setup worse then others?

------------------------------------
GO INDY OR GO HOME!
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-21-2017, 04:52 PM   #17
Guru
AZDave on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts:501
State: AZDave is an Insurance Agent from Arizona
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family AZDave is the thread starter for: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family

AMFAM owns the book. Agents become eligible for 'termination' benefits after certain number of years, and that is based on a % of the renewal.

They just cannot have it both ways; 1099 independent contractor status, but have huge controls on your agency operations.

Pony up, AMFAM.!

------------------------------------
A bad day of fishing is better than......
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-21-2017, 09:22 PM   #18
New Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts:6
State: Brianj is an Insurance Agent from
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Having worked in amfam for 10 yrs, i can tell you that yes they abused the captive setup a bunch. It was such a relief when i finally left for the indy agent route.
------------------------------------
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-24-2017, 04:04 PM   #19
Guru
 
Join Date: Nov 2014
Posts:422
State: Gulfman is an Insurance Agent from Florida
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Originally Posted by AZDave View Post
AMFAM owns the book. Agents become eligible for 'termination' benefits after certain number of years, and that is based on a % of the renewal.

They just cannot have it both ways; 1099 independent contractor status, but have huge controls on your agency operations.

Pony up, AMFAM.!
Termination Benefits....what's that? Is that some kinda "severance pay?" *Based on % of biz renewed?

THIS is "slavery" and also what 1822 has been pointing out for yrs---and i don't even know the guy.

HOWEVER, the way i'm reading it is ALL AGENTS who are "captive" will be w-2 (that's a given), but ALSO indy's as well (which technically is correct). ***WHEN PC agencies have signed agreements with 220 agents or licensed CSRs, (meaning,...those minions can't work for anyone else but me AND, i also own that BOB they bring in)----what else could they be classified as? Can anyone argue that these "agents" who can't go anywhere else, ARE anything BUT W-2?

Gotta slip "a Nice load of BS by these judges" to get this to pass mustard as 1099 contractors.

???

Gonna be a BIG PAYDAY for these Attorney's if they get this one through.
------------------------------------
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Old 04-24-2017, 04:13 PM   #20
Guru
VolAgent on Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts:12,987
State: VolAgent is an Insurance Agent from Tennessee
VolAgent is a member of 5000 posts Super VIP club
Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family Re: Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Originally Posted by Gulfman View Post
Termination Benefits....what's that? Is that some kinda "severance pay?" *Based on % of biz renewed?

THIS is "slavery" and also what 1822 has been pointing out for yrs---and i don't even know the guy.

HOWEVER, the way i'm reading it is ALL AGENTS who are "captive" will be w-2 (that's a given), but ALSO indy's as well (which technically is correct). ***WHEN PC agencies have signed agreements with 220 agents or licensed CSRs, (meaning,...those minions can't work for anyone else but me AND, i also own that BOB they bring in)----what else could they be classified as? Can anyone argue that these "agents" who can't go anywhere else, ARE anything BUT W-2?

Gotta slip "a Nice load of BS by these judges" to get this to pass mustard as 1099 contractors.

???

Gonna be a BIG PAYDAY for these Attorney's if they get this one through.
Not quite sure I followed everything you said.

The sad reality is, many people who are classified as independent contractors are really employees. The employer simply has too much control and the IC has never made an investment and has no real risk of running a loss.

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small...ed-or-employee

For an agency with workers, anyone sitting at a desk is almost certainly an employee. Outside people may or may not be an employee, it really just depends on the level of control.

If you tell someone what to do, when to do it and how to do it all while controlling how much they get paid, they are almost certainly your employee under the law.

------------------------------------
You can pay the premium or you can own the loss.
  Reply With Quote to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family
Reply to Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees?   Jammal Vs American Family 

  Insurance Agent Forum > Insurance Forums > Insurance Agents and Brokers Forum > P&C Insurance Forum




Similar Threads with Captives Soon to All Be W2 Employees? Jammal Vs American Family
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
American Family Insurance captiveagent General Insurance Agent Discussions 8 09-07-2008 09:59 AM
Allstate and American Family Insureguy Getting Started Selling Insurance 7 05-03-2008 11:37 AM
American Family term loginname General Insurance Agent Discussions 0 08-03-2007 03:43 PM
American Family is Increasing their Agency Force captiveagent General Insurance Agent Discussions 2 02-23-2007 06:12 PM



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:43 AM.

Forum enabled with vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.


Join the Forum - It's FREE

Share This Page



Weekly Poll

Where do we go from here? POLL
Nothing - No ACA fixes - status quo
29.82 %
HHS Rulings and band aid bills
17.54 %
Hail Mary repeal and/or replace bill
17.54 %
A bipartisan bill to fix ACA
35.09 %

Voters: 57. This poll is closed